failure analysis Home | Index | Search | Map
A CORROSION AND MATERIALS TECHNOLOGY SITE
Corrosion, Failure Analysis and Materials Selection are our specialities

 

III Oil and Petrochemical Industries

The use of aluminium bronzes in the oil and petrochemical industries is largely restricted to pumps, heat exchangers and valves in cooling water systems, to which the comments under Section 4(i) and Section 4(ii) generally apply.

Aluminium bronze (CA102 or UNS 60800) tubes are sometimes used with tubeplates of CA105 or CA106 in heat exchangers especially when these are operating under relatively high pressure and it is desired to weld the tubes to the tubeplates. For most purposes, however, heat exchangers are tubed with aluminium brass or, for particularly severe service conditions, with titanium and the tubeplates are of naval brass or aluminium bronze CA105 or CA106.

For coolers dealing with high pressure product streams, tube-and-shell condensers are used with sea water on the shell side and the product passing through the tubes. The shells and baffles are fabricated from CA106 ("Alloy D") plate 12 to 15 mm thick, using a duplex (9 to 10% Al) alloy as the weld filler but with a capping run of CA106. The tubeplates are also of CA106; with tubes of 70/30 copper-nickel or titanium.

Aluminium bronze bolts are usually employed on submersible cooling water pumps. Monel is more commonly used for bolting flanges on large diameter undersea oil or gas pipes but there is no reason why aluminium bronzes should not be used for this purpose. Since the pipes themselves are of steel and are cathodically protected, an alternative procedure which is often used is to fit steel bolts and flanges with a "bolt protector" filled with grease fitted round the bolt shanks, and to rely upon the cathodic protection to take care of the exposed ends.

Sea water piping ranging from approximately 50 to 350 mm diameter is used on offshore oil platforms to convey cooling water and water for injection back into the well. The first generation of North Sea platforrns used cement-lined steel for these but 90/10 copper-nickel is now frequently employed since it gives better corrosion resistance and a considerable reduction in weight. Welded aluminium bronze tubes would give at least equally good corrosion resistance and greater weight savings since the strength/weight ratio of aluminium bronzes is higher than that of 90/10 copper-nickel.

One important application of aluminium bronze in the oil industry is its use for fans in the inert gas protection systems on board oil tankers.

These fans are used to maintain the flow and pressure of the inert gas blanket over the oil cargo so as to obviate the danger of explosion or fire. The inert gas used is produced from the exhaust gas from the main engines, auxiliary engines or sometimes from a special generator, by "scrubbing" with sea water. The fan operating conditions can be very corrosive and far from easy to predict, involving salt-laden water vapour, sulphurous gases and traces of carbon. Several materials have been used to construct the fans, many of which are large and run at high speeds. Only titanium and aluminium bronze have been found to give reliable service and, of these, aluminium bronze is far less expensive. The smaller fans may use cast impellers but the larger ones are fabricated by welding.

iv Specific Corrosive Chemical Environments

The general policy in the chemical manufacturing industries is to construct equipment of mild steel wherever possible and to use stainless steel for those parts where the corrosion resistance of mild steel is inadequate. Copper-base alloys tend to be used mainly in cooling water pumps and valves. Aluminium bronzes are, however, also used for small items in a very wide variety of chemical environments where high resistance to corrosion and erosion are required.

 

Acidic Environments

Aluminium bronzes are often used in processes employing sulphuric acid. Their corrosion resistance depends upon the composition and metallurgical structure of the alloy as well as upon temperature, concentration and degree of aeration or presence of oxidising agents in the acid. Single phase aluminium bronzes generally show the highest resistance to sulphuric acid but alpha-beta alloys are satisfactory provided that they are free from gamma 2 phase. Nickel aluminium bronzes are also satisfactory provided that they are free from retained beta but, unless the higher strength of these alloys is required, a single phase alloy is generally preferred. The effects of temperature and of concentration are not simple and can only be determined experimentally. Figure 3 shows the relationship between temperature, sulphuric acid concentration and corrosion rate for nickel aluminium bronze in the presence of oxygen. Aeration increases the rate of corrosion of aluminium bronzes in sulphuric acid and greater acceleration is caused by the presence of oxidising agents such as ferric salts, dichromates or nitric acid.

The corrosion rate of aluminium bronzes in hydrochloric acid is very much higher than in sulphuric acid and aluminium bronzes are not usually suitable for handling hydrochloric acid solutions (See Table 8). One exception to this general rule is the use of cast AB2 aluminium bronze as pickling hooks for descaling coils of steel wire rod in warm, moderately strong hydrochloric acid. This, however, depends upon the sacrificial cathodic protection which is afforded to the aluminium bronze by the steel.

Table 8 gives corrosion rates for Cu 9%Al in hydrochloric acid. Note that the presence of oxidising agents increases the attack.

Table 9 (also from Rabald) gives corrosion rates in pure 20% and 60% phosphoric acid in long term tests.

Table 8 Corrosion Rates for Cu. 9%Al in Hydrochloric Acid

Table 8 is taken from E. Rabald, Corrosion Guide, Second Edition, Elsevier Publishing Company, Amsterdam-London-New York, 1965. Rabald comments "The greater attack at 100°C and 15% HCI is caused by the higher air content" and notes that the solubility of oxygen at 100°C is higher in 15% HCl than in 30% HCI.

Table 9 Corrosion Rates for Cu 10%AI in Phosphoric Acid mm/year

The good resistance of aluminium bronzes to corrosion by hydrofluoric acid is exploited in the "frosting" of glass bulbs for electric lamps. Nickel aluminium bronze is used for the nozzles which spray acid into the bulbs and the trays which collect the acid from the process.

Aluminium bronze can be used with other non-oxidizing acids - including most organic acids - and high concentrations of phosphoric and acetic acid have been handled industrially at elevated temperatures. Nitric acid solutions are strongly oxidising and produce rates of attack on aluminium bronze which preclude their use in that environment.

Figure 3. Corrosion rate of nickel aluminium bronze, CA 104, in sulphuric acid in the presence of oxygen.

Corrosion rates for aluminium bronzes in non-oxidizing conditions depend upon acid concentration and temperature. Figure 3 gives data for nickel aluminium bronze in sulphuric acid. This is from information provided by Langley Alloys Limited and was previously published in "The Aluminium Bronzes. Properties and Production Processes", Copper Development Association. London, 1938.

Alkaline Environments

Strongly alkaline environments such as caustic soda or caustic potash solutions remove the protective alumina film from aluminium bronzes and result in steady and moderately high dissolution rates. Less strongly alkaline solutions and moist alkaline chemicals such as sodium or potassium carbonates can be handled satisfactorily. In common with all copper alloys aluminium bronze suffers general corrosion, and shows suceptibility to stress corrosion cracking, in environments containing ammonia.

Table 10 Uses of Aluminium Bronzes in Corrosive Chemical Environments

Table 10 presents information taken from E. Rabald, Corrosion Guide, Second Edition, Elsevier Publishing Company, Amsterdam-London-New York, 1968. It lists industrial uses of aluminium bronzes in contact with corrosive chemicals where corrosion rates of < 2.4 g/m2 per day (0.008 mm per year) were recorded. The list by no means covers all industrial uses of aluminium bronzes in chemical industry and excludes cases where aluminium bronzes have been used successfully but with corrosion rates somewhat higher than those specified above. The information provided by Rabald does not always include details of the particular aluminium bronzes concerned. Where this is the case, a dash has been inserted under the heading "Alloy" in Table 10.

v Resistance to Atmospheric Corrosion and Oxidation

Aluminium bronzes preserve their original golden colour for long periods under normal atmospheric exposure conditions which would produce green patination on copper, brass and most other copper alloys. Little quantitative information is available on the long-term corrosion resistance of aluminium bronzes in the atmosphere but a 7% aluminium, 2% silicon aluminium bronze, similar to UNS 63900, was included in ASTM twenty-year atmospheric exposure tests commenced in 1957. The final results have yet to be published, but after seven years, this alloy showed average corrosion rates lower than those of any other copper alloys tested.

The high resistance of aluminium bronzes to atmospheric corrosion combined with their ability to carry heavy loads at low rubbing speeds without undue wear or distortion makes them particularly suitable for bearing bushes in aircraft frames. Nickel aluminium bronze, CA104, is widely employed for this purpose.

Sulphur dioxide pollution is an important cause of corrosion of most metals under atmospheric exposure conditions and, as noted in Section 4(iv) the resistance of aluminium bronzes to sulphuric acid is high. It is not, therefore, surprising that aluminium bronze is used for access fittings for high chimneys. Another very important property of aluminium bronzes for this purpose is their low susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking. The high-temperature oxidation resistance of aluminium bronze results from the formation of a thin protective aluminium oxide film and increases with the aluminium content of the alloy. Figure 4 shows that the improvement in oxidation resistance over copper is most marked as the aluminium content is increased to about 6% - further increase of aluminium content above that level producing relatively little further improvement.

Figure 4. The influence of aluminium content on the oxidation of copper-aluminium alloys at 650°C.

vi Aluminium Bronzes in Building

The combination of high strength with good general corrosion resistance and low susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking presented by aluminium bronzes make them a preferred material for load bearing masonry fixings. For fixings made from wrought rod or sections the best alloy is CA104; the corresponding cast alloy AB2 is generally used for cast fixings and sockets though AB1 is sometimes employed.

The appearance and tarnish resistance of aluminium bronzes make them suitable for decorative architectural features but their relatively high price compared with brasses and high tensile brasses limits their use for this purpose. A specialized application for aluminium bronze in building is as reinforcement bars or clamps used in the repair of old stonework. Restorations of stonework carried out in the nineteenth century were commonly made using cast or wrought iron for reinforcement and subsequent rusting of the reinforcement has resulted in severe further damage to the stonework. Aluminium bronze is the most suitable of the copper alloys for this purpose, not only because of its high resistance to general corrosion and to stress corrosion cracking but because its high strength enables bars and clamps of relatively small section to be used, with correspondingly less damage to the old stonework during installation of the reinforcement.

  < < < click here to go back to the previous page  ::

Last Updated: February 16, 2004
Copyright © 2001-2004 The Hendrix Group. All Rights Reserved.

The Hendrix Group, Inc.
15823 N. Barkers Landing
Houston, Texas 77079
Phone: (281) 556-8774
Fax: (281) 870-0659
Email: info@hghouston.com



Technical Reference | Engineering Services | Case Histories | Index
Sitemap | Links | Search | Corporate Info | Staff | Contact
Home | Newsletters | Discussion Forums | Members Only

Site Design by M Media